3 Reasons To Never Plant Butterfly Bush Again

Sure, butterfly bushes are gorgeous, but planting one comes at a big cost to your local ecosystem

February 27, 2017
butterfly bush with monarch butterfly
Joe-Tindall/ Getty

If someone took 75 percent of your food away, you wouldn't be a happy camper. But when you grow the invasive species butterfly bush, and other plants that provide only nectar, that's what you're doing to birds and butterflies in your own backyard. (Here’s more on why butterfly bush gets a well-deserved bad rap.) 

A leading wildlife ecologist wants you to start thinking about your property—no matter how big or small—as an important link in your local ecosystem. It's no exaggeration to say that when you choose which plants to include in your garden, even the beautiful, seemingly harmless butterfly bush, you're deciding if members of your community's local food web will be nourished or unintentionally starved.

And to get to that mind frame, which is a way of thinking that truly benefits nature, including its butterflies, you're going to have to come to a harsh realization: You need to stop planting the butterfly bush—forever. (Here are 10 more plants you should never, ever grow.)

We turned to Doug Tallamy, PhD, professor and chair of entomology and wildlife ecology at the University of Delaware, to give us the hard truth about butterfly bush. 

(On just a quarter-acre of land, you can produce fresh, organic food for a family of four—year-round. Rodale's The Backyard Homestead shows you how; get your copy today.)

butterfly bush is invasive
Whiteway/Getty
Problem 1: Butterfly Bush Doesn't Stay In Your Yard

Butterfly bush is an invasive plant, meaning it outcompetes and crowds out beneficial native plants that have been naturally growing in your community for centuries. In this country, butterfly bush, which has origins in Asia, readily spreads and takes over space where native plants—the ones naturally selected to nourish the local food web (the birds, butterflies, and moths most people love to watch in their yards)—would normally thrive. In fact, Buddleja davidii (the scientific name for butterfly bush) has life history traits that make it invasive in most environments.

"I hear the 'it's invasive here, but not over there' argument a lot," says Tallamy. "While it is invasive in many parts of the U.S., what's really important is that the plant has the ability to be invasive almost anywhere. If it's not in some place, chances are good it will be [at some point]. They become invasive when they reach a certain density, when lots of people plant it."

Butterfly bushes move around. There's clear documentation of butterfly bush invasions on Superfund restoration sites that are supposed to be grasslands. In Hawaii, there are some islands that are virtually all butterfly bushes. 

"People who say butterfly bush doesn't move around are in the denial stage," Tallamy says. "I wouldn't fight it as much as I do if it weren't invasive, but butterfly bush just doesn't stay where we plant it." 

And when you get right down to it, do your private property rights to grow what you want trump those of the plants, animals, and even other people around you? "I wish people would know that what they do on their property impacts other properties and natural areas. Do they have the right to do that? I would argue no, they don't," Tallamy says.

Related: Butterfly Gardening—Without Invasive Species

butterfly bush monarch caterpillar
Raquel Lonas/ Getty
Problem 2: Butterfly Bush Doesn't Really Benefit Butterflies

There's no denying that butterfly bush's long, narrow tufts of flowers are beautiful. And like many flowering plants, it is a good nectar plant. But when it's the only plant you grow for butterflies, you're not going to have butterflies anymore, Tallamy warns. 

What butterflies are desperately in need of are proper host plants so they can reproduce, and their larval offspring can feed on host plant leaves. Instead of being sucked in by butterfly bush's beauty, start making the connection between plants, butterflies, and other members of the food web, and work more native host plants into your landscape, such as butterfly weed, other milkweeds, joe-pye weed, and oak trees.

"People rationalize their perceived need for butterfly bush because they think it helps butterflies," Tallamy says. "What they really want is a pretty plant in their yard."

Related: 5 Ways Your Garden Can Support The Local Wildlife

Advertisement
Advertisement
 
butterfly bush food web
BirdImages/ Getty
Problem 3: Butterfly Bush Is Contributing To The Collapse Of Food Webs

Here's the harsh truth: Planting nonnative plants, like butterfly bush, in your yard is actually making it harder for the butterflies and birds in your neighborhood to survive. (Here’s how to make birds fall in love with your backyard.) 

For instance, if you want chickadees to breed in your yard, you need plants that will produce to support the 6,000 to 9,000 caterpillars the birds need during the 16 days when they are feeding their young. "If you don't have that, the chickadees—the plant-caterpillar-chickadee food web—stops," Tallamy explains. "If you plant butterfly bush, and not natives, then right away you're removing at least 75 percent of the food that is supporting the biodiversity that's out there."

And critters need all the help they can get. One-third of plants in North America aren't actually native to North America. And get this: 80 percent of plants in our yards aren't native. "The impact of all of these nonnative plants is creating novel ecosystems that are not supporting food webs, therefore not supporting biodiversity," Tallamy says. "We're seeing an entire collapse."

Related: 4 Ways To Stop A Monarch Butterfly Collapse

See Next