How To Make Better Pizza At Home—According To A Pizza Professor

There's nothing as satisfying as making your own pies; here's how to perfect basic dough and healthier toppings.

August 9, 2017
We hope you enjoy the products we're recommending as much as we do! Just so you know, Organic Life may get a share of sales from the links on this page.
how to make pizza dough and more tips for how to make pizza at home
Lumina Images/Getty

What’s more fun than a pizza party? A party with fresh, homemade pizza pies right from your own oven.

Next time you get family or friends together for pizza and everyone's favorite toppings, try these great home pizza-making tips offered by Mark Bello of Pizza a Casa, a "pizza school" in New York City. In his popular cooking classes, Bello teaches people how to make pizzeria-quality pies in their home ovens.

We hope you enjoy the products we're recommending as much as we do! Just so you know, Organic Life may get a share of sales from the links on this page.

Check out Bello’s expert advice, and try it out with a few of our favorite homemade pizza recipes from the Rodale Recipe Finder. (If homemade pizza becomes a frequent item on your dinner menu, consider planting a pizza garden next spring for the freshest, healthiest ingredients.)

Slash your cholesterol, burn stubborn belly fat, solve your insomnia, and more—naturally!—with Rodale's Eat For Extraordinary Health & Healing!

1. Get a pizza stone

use a pizza stone for the crispest crust on your home made pizza
Photograph courtesy of

A sheet pan will work, but if you’re serious about crispy, thin-crust pizza, invest in a quality baking stone for your homemade pizza recipes. Go for something a half inch thick (Bello swears by Old Stone Oven pizza stones, available for $40 on Amazon), and get it heating up in your oven at least an hour before you plan to put in your pizza. A baking stone distributes heat evenly to the pizza and crisps up the bottom nicely.


Related: 4 Healthy Alternatives To Non-Stick Teflon Cookware

2. Be gentle on the dough

how to make pizza dough
Therese Elaine Saunders @ TD'Villas Photography/Getty

Be gentle as you stretch your dough out, or you'll literally beat the "breath" out of it, resulting in a flat, cardboard-y pizza. Be kind to your dough and it will return the favor with crispy outsides and pleasingly bready, chewy insides. (Don't worry, we have a pizza dough recipe coming right up.)

Related: How To Make Homemade Bread You Don't Have To Knead

3. Crank up the heat

to make great pizza at home, turn up the oven temperature to at least 500


Set your oven as hot as it goes. Most ovens can go to 500 or 550 degrees. Pizza-making perfection at home is possible at these temperatures.

4. Don't go overboard with toppings

to put too many toppings on home made pizza

With toppings, less is more, and go for quality over quantity. Don't overload your pizzas with either too much of any one topping or too many different toppings. Quality ingredients (such as those in this stellar kale and lemon pizza) shine in moderation, and a less-loaded-up pizza will cook better.

Related: 12 Sketchy Ingredients To Keep Out Of Your Food

5. No peeking

when making pizza at home, don't open the oven to check for doneness
Jeremy Woodhouse/Holly Wilmeth/Getty

Keep that oven door closed—no peeking! Every time you open your oven door you lose precious heat. If making more than one pie, get them in and out pronto!

The Recipes:

#1: Basic Pizza Dough. Yes, you can buy ready-made dough from your local pizza shop or in the refrigerated section of your grocery store. But did you know you can make your own with just flour, water, yeast, salt, and a bit of an arm workout? Give it a try. You can use this dough for any of the recipes below.

#2: Pizza Margherita. Classic, authentic Neapolitan-style Pizza Margherita will appeal to any pizza purist. The high-quality, simple toppings—just San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil are clean and healthy, yet deliciously satisfying.

#3: Soppressata Picante. This one is for the meat-lovers. Topped with spicy cured sausage, it’s sure to satisfy the urge for a bit of heat. 

#4: Goat Cheese and Red Pepper Pizza. A super-healthy pizza pie you can make with a whole wheat crust; the low-fat goat cheese, herbs, and roasted red peppers give it plenty of flavor.

#5: Caramelized Pear Pizza. Wrap up your pizza party with a dessert pizza. Slices of caramelized pear makes it sweet, while fat-free ricotta keeps it light.